But the Brisbane Lions lost that decider by four points to Collingwood and that pair left empty-handed.
Three seasons on and the club is on the cusp of a third successive title and set to face Fremantle at the MCG on Saturday.
But thanks to injuries and, more recently, the Lions' tremendous depth and versatility, that luckless duo are without a title and set to again spectate.
"I owe it to them to go out and play with massive effort and do it for them," Jarrod Berry said before the team travelled to Melbourne on Wednesday.
"It'll be a firecracker for us."
McCarthy, 32 and re-signed in the rookie draft on a one-year deal, will likely be an emergency on Saturday.
While initially tried in the backline as another small defence option, livewire Conor McKenna's re-emergence as a game-breaking small forward has limited McCarthy to just eight games this season.
And there is likely no room in Brisbane's dynamic defence for Coleman or fan favourite Bruce Reville, who won a flag last year.
"It's a credit to them, because they handle themselves so well and you wouldn't know they're battling behind the scenes," Berry said.
"It gives the guys with the opportunity a bit of a kick, and I know how much it hurts."Â
Berry missed last year's decider when he dislocated his shoulder in the preliminary final while Eric Hipwood also watched on as he recovered from a second knee reconstruction.
"That (first one) made last year a lot easier and I had Linc and Kiddy to lean on for advice," Hipwood, who kicked a screamer in the Lions' 2024 grand final win, said.
"And I was still able to see my best mates win a final. I was still so happy.
"There's always a fairytale and always a hard luck story, but we all know it takes much more than just the 23 who play on the day."
6°C